BeltStack

Square Payroll Review (2026)

4.3RatingBest for: small businesses already using Square for payments or point of saleStarting price: $35/moPayroll types: W-2, 1099
Visit Square Payroll

Quick verdict

Our take in a nutshell.

Square Payroll makes sense if you already use Square for payments, point of sale, or invoicing. Payroll ties into the same account so you have one login and a consistent experience. It handles W-2 and 1099 payroll, tax filing, and direct deposit. The focus is on simplicity rather than a long list of HR or benefits features.

We like Square Payroll for ease of setup and a clear, uncluttered interface. If you're a small team and Square is already your hub for taking payments or managing your business, adding payroll is a natural fit. The drawback is that HR and benefits depth lag behind Gusto or Rippling—you get solid payroll basics, not a full HR platform.

Limitations: Less robust for advanced HR, benefits administration, or complex multi-state setups compared to Gusto or OnPay. Best for small businesses that prioritize simplicity and Square integration over breadth.

Rating breakdown

How we scored this product.

  • Features

    4.2

    Solid payroll and tax filing; W-2 and 1099. Fewer HR and benefits features than Gusto or Rippling. Good for basic payroll needs.

  • Pricing

    4.4

    Published pricing (e.g. base plus per employee). Competitive for small teams. Straightforward and easy to understand.

  • Ease of Use

    4.6

    Simple setup and interface. Especially easy if you already use Square; one ecosystem to learn.

  • Support

    4.2

    Support via Square's channels. Adequate for small business; less specialized payroll support than some competitors.

  • Integrations

    4.5

    Best integration is with Square's own products. Connects to some accounting tools; ecosystem is more Square-centric than broad.

Pros and cons

What we liked and what to watch for.

Pros

  • Simple setup and easy to use
  • Good fit if you already use Square
  • W-2 and 1099 payroll with tax filing
  • Published, predictable pricing
  • Unified experience with Square apps

Cons

  • Less HR and benefits depth than Gusto or Rippling
  • Best value inside the Square ecosystem
  • Fewer integrations than some payroll-only platforms

Who this software is best for

Ideal users and use cases.

Square Payroll is best for small businesses that already use Square for payments, POS, or invoicing and want straightforward payroll without a separate vendor. Ideal for very small teams, sole proprietors with a few employees, and businesses that prefer to keep everything in Square.

Who should avoid it

Businesses that don't use Square and don't plan to may get more value from Gusto or OnPay, which offer broader HR and integrations. If you need deep HR, benefits administration, or the strongest accounting integrations outside Square, look elsewhere.

Pricing overview

What to expect to pay.

Square Payroll uses published pricing—typically a monthly base plus per-employee or per-contractor fee. Pricing is competitive for small teams. Check Square's current rates for your state and headcount.

Square offers payroll plans with clear base and per-person pricing. Add-ons may apply for certain features. Simpler structure than tiered products like Gusto.

Square Payroll is often competitive with entry-level Gusto or OnPay for very small teams. The main differentiator is Square integration; if you're not on Square, compare feature sets and total cost with Gusto and Patriot.

Starting price: $35/mo

Key features

What stands out.

  • Square ecosystem integration

    Payroll lives in your Square account alongside payments and other tools. One login, consistent experience.

  • Simple payroll

    Run pay for employees and contractors. Tax filing and deposits are handled. Focus on essentials rather than advanced HR.

  • 1099 support

    Pay contractors and handle 1099-NEC. Suitable for small teams with a mix of W-2 and 1099.

Integrations

Plays well with your stack.

Square Payroll is strongest when used with Square's own products. If you run your business on Square, payroll fits in naturally. For non-Square users, integration options are more limited than with Gusto or QuickBooks Payroll.

  • Square POS
  • Square Invoices
  • Square Dashboard
  • Some accounting integrations

How contractors use this software

Real-world workflows for trade businesses.

  • Small teams on Square: Add payroll without leaving the Square ecosystem. Pay employees and contractors from the same place you run payments.
  • Simple pay runs: Straightforward payroll and tax filing without extra HR modules.

Alternatives

Other options we review.

  • Gusto

    More HR and benefits; better if you're not tied to Square.

  • QuickBooks Payroll

    Best if you use QuickBooks for accounting instead of Square.

  • Patriot Payroll

    Budget-friendly payroll; good if you want low cost and don't need Square.

Compare with other payroll software

See how Square Payroll stacks up head-to-head.

Best payroll software for different use cases

Find payroll software by scenario.

Square Payroll FAQs

Quick answers.