BeltStack

Square Payroll vs Gusto (2026)

Square Payroll and Gusto both offer payroll and tax filing, but they target different users. Square Payroll is built for simplicity inside the Square ecosystem—if you already use Square for payments or POS, adding payroll is straightforward. Gusto is built for stronger HR and benefits depth and works with any accounting setup. This comparison breaks down who each fits best.

Square Payroll

4.3 rating

From $35/mo

Simple payroll for businesses already using the Square ecosystem.

Visit Square Payroll

Gusto

4.8 rating

From $40/mo

Small businesses that want stronger HR and benefits depth with transparent pricing.

Visit Gusto

Quick recommendation

  • Square Payroll: Best for businesses already using Square who want simple payroll in the same ecosystem.
  • Gusto: Best for businesses that want stronger HR and benefits depth with transparent pricing.

Quick verdict

How these two tools differ.

Square Payroll is designed to sit inside a Square account: simple payroll, tax filing, and contractor support with straightforward pricing. Gusto is a standalone payroll and HR platform with more hiring tools, PTO, benefits administration, and integrations. Both handle W-2 and 1099 payroll with automatic tax filing.

Square Payroll wins on simplicity and ecosystem fit—if you're already on Square, adding payroll is easy and your data stays in one place. Gusto wins on HR and benefits depth: more features for onboarding, PTO, health, and 401(k) in one product. For businesses that don't use Square, Gusto (or OnPay) is usually the better fit. For Square users who want minimal complexity, Square Payroll is a strong choice.

Pricing is comparable at entry: Square Payroll often starts around $35/month base plus per-person fees; Gusto's Simple plan starts at $40/month. Gusto's tiers add more HR and features; Square Payroll stays simple. Choose Square Payroll if you're in the Square ecosystem and want straightforward payroll. Choose Gusto if you want more HR and benefits and don't need to stay inside Square.

See our full Square Payroll review →See our full Gusto review →

Comparison summary

Winner for Square ecosystem

Square Payroll

Payroll lives inside Square with your payments and POS.

Winner for HR and benefits

Gusto

Gusto offers more hiring, PTO, and benefits in one platform.

Quick decision guide

Which product fits your situation.

Choose Square Payroll if:

  • You already use Square for payments, POS, or other services.
  • You want simple payroll without deep HR or many add-ons.
  • You prefer to keep payments and payroll in one ecosystem.
  • Your needs are straightforward—pay runs and tax filing.

Choose Gusto if:

  • You want more HR and benefits features (hiring, PTO, health, 401k).
  • You're not tied to Square and want a standalone payroll and HR platform.
  • You value transparent tiered pricing and a modern, feature-rich product.
  • You need stronger contractor self-service and compliance tools.

Ratings comparison

How we score each product.

CategorySquare PayrollGusto
Ease of use4.54.9
Features4.24.8
Pricing4.44.6
Support4.24.5
Integrations4.04.7

Feature comparison

Side-by-side feature check.

SupportedPartial supportNot available

FeatureSquare PayrollGusto
Payroll automationFull W-2 and 1099Full W-2 and 1099, unlimited pay runs
Tax filingAutomatic federal and stateAutomatic federal and state
HR toolsBasicStrong: hiring, PTO, onboarding, documents
Benefits administrationAvailable; may be limitedHealth, 401(k), and more built in
Square ecosystemNative—payments and payroll togetherIntegrates with Square but not native
Ease of useSimple; good if you use SquareVery easy; modern UI, guided setup

Pricing comparison

What to expect to pay.

Square Payroll uses published pricing—often around $35/month base plus per-employee or per-contractor fees. Gusto uses tiered pricing (e.g. $40/month on Simple plus per-person). At entry they're close; Gusto adds more HR and benefits on higher tiers. Square Payroll stays simple. Compare total monthly cost at your headcount; if you're already on Square, Square Payroll can be the most straightforward add.

Pros and cons

Strengths and trade-offs.

Square Payroll

Pros

  • Simple payroll inside Square
  • Straightforward pricing and setup
  • Good if you already use Square
  • No separate payroll vendor to manage

Cons

  • Less HR and benefits depth than Gusto
  • Tied to Square ecosystem
  • Fewer integrations outside Square

Gusto

Pros

  • Stronger HR and benefits in one platform
  • Transparent pricing; works with any accounting setup
  • Strong contractor self-service and 1099 support
  • More integrations and add-ons

Cons

  • Not native to Square—separate product
  • Slightly higher base than Square Payroll in some cases
  • More features can mean more to learn

Best for

Which tool fits your situation.

Best for Square ecosystem users

Square Payroll is the better fit when you already use Square and want simple payroll in the same place. Gusto is the better fit when you want stronger HR and benefits and aren't tied to Square.

Best for HR and benefits depth

Gusto is the better fit for more HR and benefits features—hiring, PTO, health, 401(k)—in one product. Square Payroll is the better fit for simplicity and staying inside Square.

Alternatives

Other options we review.

OnPay

Flat pricing and straightforward payroll.

Read review →Patriot Payroll

Budget-friendly payroll; good for cost-conscious small business.

Read review →QuickBooks Payroll

Best if you use QuickBooks for accounting.

Read review →

More comparisons

Read full reviews

Dive deeper into each product.

For detailed ratings, features, and pros and cons, see our standalone reviews:

Best payroll software guides

Find the right fit by use case or trade.

FAQs

Quick answers.