Payroll Software Comparisons
Compare the top payroll software platforms side-by-side—including Gusto, QuickBooks Payroll, ADP, Paychex, and OnPay. Our head-to-head comparisons break down features, pricing, pros and cons, and automation so you can choose the best payroll tool for your business.
Whether you need payroll for contractors and W-2 employees, tax filing, or HR and benefits, these side-by-side reviews help you see which platform fits your size, budget, and workflow.
Popular Comparisons
Side-by-side features, pricing, and recommendations.
Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll
Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll both handle W-2 and 1099 payroll with automatic tax filing, but they target different workflows. Gusto is a sta…
Compare →
Gusto vs OnPay
Gusto and OnPay both serve small businesses with payroll, tax filing, and benefits, but they take different approaches. Gusto offers more HR…
Compare →
Gusto vs ADP
Gusto and ADP both offer payroll, tax filing, and HR, but they serve different scales. Gusto is built for small businesses with transparent…
Compare →
Gusto vs Paychex
Gusto and Paychex both offer payroll, tax filing, and HR, but they appeal to different preferences. Gusto is the modern, self-serve option w…
Compare →QuickBooks Payroll vs OnPay
QuickBooks Payroll and OnPay both serve small businesses with payroll and tax filing, but they take different approaches. QuickBooks Payroll…
Compare →ADP vs Paychex
ADP and Paychex are two of the largest full-service payroll and HR providers. Both use custom pricing and serve small business through enter…
Compare →Paychex vs OnPay
Paychex and OnPay serve very different preferences: Paychex is a full-service provider with custom pricing and strong support; OnPay is a mo…
Compare →
Rippling vs Gusto
Rippling and Gusto both offer payroll and HR, but they target different needs. Rippling is built for growing businesses that want payroll pl…
Compare →Rippling vs QuickBooks Payroll
Rippling and QuickBooks Payroll serve different centers of gravity: Rippling offers payroll plus HR and IT in one platform with broad workfo…
Compare →
Square Payroll vs Gusto
Square Payroll and Gusto both offer payroll and tax filing, but they target different users. Square Payroll is built for simplicity inside t…
Compare →Square Payroll vs QuickBooks Payroll
Square Payroll and QuickBooks Payroll are both straightforward payroll options tied to an ecosystem: Square for payments and POS, QuickBooks…
Compare →
Patriot Payroll vs Gusto
Patriot Payroll and Gusto sit at different ends of the small-business payroll spectrum: Patriot is built for budget-conscious owners who wan…
Compare →Patriot Payroll vs OnPay
Patriot Payroll and OnPay both serve small businesses with straightforward payroll and tax filing, but they take different approaches. Patri…
Compare →
Justworks vs Gusto
Justworks and Gusto both offer payroll plus benefits and HR, but Justworks is a PEO with custom pricing and large-group benefits, while Gust…
Compare →
Deel vs Gusto
Deel is built for global contractor and employee payments and EOR; Gusto is built for US small-business payroll and HR. If you have only US…
Compare →
Wave vs Gusto
Wave offers free accounting with a payroll add-on for micro businesses; Gusto offers full payroll, benefits, and HR with published pricing.…
Compare →Wave vs QuickBooks Payroll
Wave offers free accounting with a payroll add-on; QuickBooks Payroll runs inside QuickBooks for businesses that already use Intuit's ecosys…
Compare →Compare by Software
Find every comparison that includes a given platform.
Compare Gusto
Compare QuickBooks Payroll
Compare Rippling
Compare Square Payroll
Compare Patriot Payroll
Compare ADP
Compare Paychex
Compare Justworks
Compare Deel
Compare SurePayroll
Compare Wave
How We Compare Payroll Software
Consistent criteria so you can compare with confidence.
Our payroll comparisons use the same evaluation criteria across every head-to-head. We look at ease of use, pricing transparency, automation and tax handling, integrations with accounting and time tools, and HR and benefits depth—so you see how each platform really stacks up.
- Ease of use — Setup, day-to-day payroll runs, and clarity of the interface.
- Pricing — Published vs custom pricing, base and per-person costs, and add-ons.
- Automation — Tax filing, direct deposit, and recurring payroll automation.
- Integrations — Accounting (QuickBooks, Xero), time tracking, and other tools.
- HR tools — Onboarding, compliance, benefits administration, and support.
For our full review process and affiliate disclosure, see our methodology page. For in-depth guides on pricing, 1099 contractors, and industry-specific payroll, see our payroll guides.